Showing posts with label LEED. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LEED. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

[281] Chutes and Stairwells

Interesante sugerencia hecha por Antigonum que decidi indagar, aprovechando el dia medio feriado de hoy, tecnicamente es feriado en una oficina y regular en la otra (pero como la otra me debe todo un fin de semana trabajando we are even).

La sugerencia fue en el articulo [279]: http://alcantarillaalquimica.blogspot.com/2012/07/279-curiosidades-web.html

Y abunda sobre un viejo articulo relacionado a la arquitectura persa y su manejo de sistemas de agua.  En aquel articulo: http://alcantarillaalquimica.blogspot.com/2010/02/los-qanat-en-el-medio-oriente.html
Exponia que los persas eran sumamente ingeniosos y usaban sistemas de ventilacion e irrigacion naturales para sus sistemas.  Quise entrar en un poco mas de detalle sobre ejemplos de esos sistemas y encontre un buen resumen aqui de tres ejemplos de gran relevancia para edificios verdes:


http://www.yellowbluedesigns.com/2012/03/05/3-beautiful-ancient-passive-cooling-techniques-in-modern-architecture/
O sea, la arquitectura moderna comienza a visualizar la simpleza y funcionalidad de estos dise/nos milenarios.  Entre ellos:
[1] Stepwells como el mostrado arriba que sirven de embalse, area de esparcimiento y acceso al nivel freatico por seco que este arriba.
[2] Estructuras para colectar los vientos superficiales para asi ventilar naturalmente los pasillos y estructuras debajo.  Si combinamos esto con un stepwell o un qanat tenemos un sistema de air chiller natural.  O sea aire acondicionado naturalmente.
[3] El uso de quiebrasoles combinados con pasillos de 4 pies de ancho cerrados con quiebrasoles permite la creacion de brisa natural a la vez que estratifica el aire del pasillo del del resto de las estructuras.  Al calentar el quiebrasol en vez del edificio se logra un edificio con un interior mucho mas fresco.

Este articulo enfocara mas en los stepwells.  EL pie forzado para este articulo comienza aqui:
http://jardinssansfrontiers.blogspot.com/2011/03/step-well-back-in-jodhpur-to-enjoy-this.html

Step wells (known locally as bawdi or baoli) are unique to the Western Indian states - a form of water management dating back to the 6th century - conceived to overcome extreme weather conditions in Rajasthan and Gujarat, where there is monsoon for three months of the year, followed by nine months of drought. Construction involved the digging of huge trenches, lined with stone blocks and steps, allowing access to the falling water table throughout the dry months.
The 3,500 Escher style steps at Abhaneri step well descend 13 stories to access water in the dry season

There are step wells throughout India's Western states and one of the finest is found at Abhaneri (above) near Jaipur, where 3500 Escher-style steps descend 13 stories to access the water below. This baori incorporates a temple, and would have served not just as a functional building, but also a meeting place and somewhere to worship, given the scarcity of water in the long, dry months.
 
Este articulo debajo enfoca en los aspectos de insalubridad que trajeron los ingleses a este tipo de cisterna.  Su argumento era que al a/nadir ofrendas de alimentos, flores, aceites, etc. y no tener manera de decantarlos contamina la fuente de agua, por lo que optaron por prohibirlos y sustituirlos por estaciones mecanicas de bombeo.  Sin embargo, entiendo que eso se resolvia con un sistema combinado de filtracion.
http://books.google.com.pr/books?id=KoVCliqcmIIC&pg=PA163&lpg=PA163&dq=stepwells+outside+india&source=bl&ots=pfp7qj61YP&sig=rHNA1rFLVatwBzfey63V7B2HFmM&hl=en&sa=X&ei=gAcQUNrGBIay8QSf0YCgCQ&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=stepwells%20outside%20india&f=false
 
Mas temas genericos de Stepwells aqui:
One of the earliest existing stepwells was built in the 11th century in Gujarat and is known as the Mata Bhavani's vav. A long flight of steps leads to the water below a sequence of multi-story open pavilions positioned along the east/west axis. The elaborate ornamentation of the columns, brackets and beams are a prime example of how stepwells were used as a form of art.[8]
The British rule of the Indian subcontinent of that time was not satisfied with the quality of hygiene that existed in these stepwells and instead installed pipes and pumps to replace their purpose. In fact, even the invasion by Mughal rulers did disrupt in the culture practiced in these stepwells. As a matter of fact, they encouraged the building of many stepwells. It was strictly the British that forced abandonment of the wells. Consequentially, the social and religious activity taken place in these places were lost to the authority of the British.[9]
The importance of water to the locations in which they were found have been realized in the past decade now that many communities in the area are scarcity of rain and water. The construction of these wells encouraged the incorporation of water into the culture where they were popular. These stepwells were even proven to be well built after withstanding earthquakes in the range of 7.6 on the Richter scale.[10]


In the northern Indian states of Rajasthan and Gujarat, the problem of water is a profound one. At the edge of the Thar desert, the area sees torrential seasonal monsoons, and then watches the water disappear almost immediately. With summers routinely over 100 degrees, and silty soil that would not hold water in ponds, a practical solution was needed for locals and travelers along the local trade routes.
In the first century AD, the slippery shores of the major rivers were tamed by the construction of ghats, long, shallow sets of stairs and landings. The same approach was applied to the construction of a new kind of well.
The earliest stepwells most likely date to about 550 AD, but the most famous were built in medieval times. It is estimated that over 3000 stepwells were built in the two northern states. Although many have fallen into disrepair, were silted in in antiquity, or were filled in with trash in the modern era, hundreds of wells still exist. In New Delhi alone, there are more than 30.
Water plays a special part in Hindu mythology, as a boundary between heaven and earth known as tirtha. As man-made tirtha, the stepwells became not only sources of drinking water, but cool sanctuaries for bathing, prayer and meditation.
The wells are called by many names. In Hindu they are baori, baoli, baudi, bawdi or bavadi. In Gujarati, spoken in Gujarat, they are commonly called vav.
The architecture of the wells varies by type and by location, and when they were built. Two common types are a step pond, with a large open top and graduated sides meeting at a relatively shallow depth. The step well type usually incorporates a narrow shaft, protected from direct sunlight by a full or partial roof, ending in a deeper, rounded well-end. Temples and resting areas with beautiful carvings are built into many of the wells. In their prime, many of them were painted in bright colors of lime-based paint, and now traces of ancient colors cling to dark corners.
The use and conditions of stepwells began to decline in the years of the British Raj, who were horrified by the unsanitary conditions of these drinking water bathing spots. They began to install pumps and pipes, and eventually outlawed the use of stepwells in some places.
The remaining stepwells are in varying states of preservation, and some have gone dry. Local kids seem to find the ones with water to be terrific diving spots, which seems insanely hazardous.


http://thinkinginsomniac.wordpress.com/2011/02/24/architecture-sketch-stepwells-vavs-in-gujarat-india/

Me llamo la atencion este analisis humanista del proposito de estos stairwells:
http://www.the-utopian.org/post/2340612672/stepwells-and-civilization
The user of the well — when it was still operational — could throw a bucket down into the shaft directly, or be social and walk down the steps to the source. The walk wasn’t necessarily arduous; in the rainy season water could rise as much as three stories, subtracting more than a handful of stairs. Now the steps were damp and mossy, as they are for much of the year, and the water was little more than a rain-fed puddle at the heart of the temple. The Rudabai Stepwell, rejected first by the British for fear of breeding ringworm, and then cheated by water-tables that sank past its reach, is desiccated and defunct — like most stepwells. In 1982, water came up to the second landing of the structure; in 1995, to the fourth; now, unless the rain is stupendous, it refuses to rise at all. The groundwater is too depleted. The first structure in sight as you exit into a dusty courtyard is a monstrous water tank shaped like an upturned drum. This is the community’s source of sustainence.
But the religious purpose of the stepwell still persists. On one hand, the Rudabai Stepwell has been co-opted completely by Hindus — a small, squat, whitewashed temple, built a half-century ago, brashly shares its wall with the southern end of the vav — and on the other, it offers up its sandstone ledges as a sort of museum of cross-religious borrowings. Hindu and Muslim motifs abound and interact. The panels of half-lotuses and flowers running along the walls and the voluptuous inner-leaf vines framed in tiny shrines are patently Islamic in their austerity; the friezes and niches are Hindu. Stepping from platform to platform, I came upon a carving of erotic girls churning butter; a conch of Shiva pressed into the ground; and a few freshly-bathed devotees praying to a shrine of Bhageshwari Devi, the 500 year-old statue freshened with dabs of vermillion powder and curlicues of incense-smoke.
Such secular style is highly unusual, particularly when examined in the glare of Gujarat’s troubled communal history. Cleaved by history and politics, Hindus and Muslims have always lived in an uneasy truce here, but since the anti-Muslim riots of March 2002, the truce has begun to feel more and more like an ambush. The Hindu nationalist Government accused of directing the pogrom is still in power and is presiding over great prosperity. The ills of the state are blamed on Muslims, who are said to reproduce at terrific rates. How do the people of Gujarat live with the thousands of lives that were lost and ruined? The caretaker said, “Outsiders did it. Vajpayee” — the then Prime Minister of India — “did it.” Then he pointed across the top of the stepwell to a man who was squatting over its edge, and said, “Look, he’s a Muslim, and he’s my friend. The riots are a city problem. In villages it was never a problem.” And so it was. Other people I met made rote gestures of communal harmony; a few dipped with evident pain into accounts of mutilations; the majority were consumed by the recent spate of bomb blasts by home-bred Islamic militants. But for most the past remained debatable; everyone was too overwhelmed by the present to mourn.

Cierro diciendo lo interesante de como estas antiguas estructuras no eran para ser temporeras sino para pasar de generacion tras generacion...
 

Friday, March 25, 2011

Planificacion Necesaria - Tema 3 - Manejo Escorrentia

Como introducir este tema de hidrologia basica sin mencionar estadisticas de eventos extremos, climatologia o usar ecuaciones extra/nas?  Quiero correlacionar lo que pasa con derrumbes, sitios que no se inundaban y ahora desbordan de agua o erosion donde no debe ocurrir.  Como hacerlo?

Comencemos con la moda del barril.  Algo que se ha puesto de moda entre los horticultores aficionados del norte.  No dudo que la moda llegue aqui en algun momento, con el auspicio de algunos ambientalistas de escritorio.  El concepto es sencillo y llegamos a hacerlo en mi casa.  Colectas el agua del chorro del techo en un dron (contenedor) de 55 galones, que luego usas para irrigar las plantas.

Suena lindo, es verde, es sustentable.  Pero realmente protege el ambiente?  No lo creo.  Estos articulos debajo discuten de ese tema.  Los anglos y LEED le llaman a eso water harvesting:
http://chanceofrain.com/2011/03/rain-barrels/
http://owendell.com/blog/general/roll-out-the-rain-barrels
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania

Litmus test.  Cuanto acumula un dron?
V = 55 galones
Techo (estimado) 50 x 100 = 5000 sq ft
C = 0.8 (el 80% de lo que cae se hace escorrentia)
55 gal = (0.8)(5000 sq ft)(H en in / 12)(7.48)
H = 0.022 inches rain
un aguacero de tan poca agua.  No lo creo.  Veredicto: muy peque/no.


La lluvia normal de Puerto Rico aqui
http://www.srh.noaa.gov/sju/?n=climo_monthly_precipitation

Area Caguas 4 a 7 pulgadas de lluvia promedio mensual
Evento extremo Diez A/nos 24 horas
9 pulgadas en 24 horas

Digamos el aguacero fue de 4 pulgadas
V = (0.8)(5000 sq ft)(4 / 12)(7.48)
V = 9973 galones

Un aguacero tipico es entre 0.5 - 1.0 inches
1246 - 2493 galones

O sea, si quiero water harvesting necesito volumen.


By the way, el que quiera adquirir el documento de los eventos extremos que vea el NOAA Atlas 14 para Puerto Rico, esta en linea aqui:
http://hdsc.nws.noaa.gov/hdsc/pfds/pr/pr_pfds.html

Ese tema de por si es bien interesante, aunque es sumamente teorico.  Uno de estos dias presentare aspectos relacionados a planificacion y determinacion de cotas de inundacion.
A lo que iba.  Los eventos de lluvia, sobre todo los valores extremos generan un volumen de agua significativo.  Ese volumen esta influenciado por varios factores, a saber:

Area de Drenaje - El flujo generado es directamente proporcional al area.  Mas area, mas escorrentia.

Percolacion y Evapotranspiracion - Los efectos de percolacion del agua al terreno, la evapotranspiracion de las plantas, el tipo de suelo, la permeabilidad, vegetacion, etc. es una influencia directa a la cantidad de lluvia.  Terreno vegetativo, matorrales y arboledas retienen los golpes de agua y absorben parte de la escorrentia.  Solo un fragmento fluye.  A grandes rasgos un terreno rural con mucha vegetacion puede tener solo un 20 a 30% del agua que se convierte en escorrentia mientras que el 90% o mas del agua que cae en una loseta de hormigon se convierte en escorrentia.

Estructuras Para Disipar la Energia, retencion - El uso de muros, vallas, pocetos de retencion y otras medidas estructurales reducen la intensidad del chorro de agua, reduciendo su efecto erosivo y alargando el tiempo en lo que llega a su destino final.


Cotejen esta presentacion del hidrologo Gregory Morris y sus programas implantados en rios de Puerto Rico para desarrollar guias (eso de control de erosion costera es otro tema del tintero).
http://www.awra.org/PR2010/doc/papers/GregoryMorris_a556f230_6812.pdf

Estos elementos toman importancia cuando el sistema en Puerto Rico consiste en hacer nuevas construcciones que puedan manejar una inundacion de 100 a/nos.  Si miramos el micro, sin tener una vision global de la situacion es que tendremos muchas piezas de 100 a/nos que no inundan pero que desvian sus aguas a otros lados.

Ese tema de por si es bien complicado.  A lo que voy.  Nuestra planificacion debe incorporar la evaluacion de sistemas que acumulen o desvien aguas de escorrentia excesivas para luego soltarlas poco a poco.  Como introduccion al tema les dejo par de links.  Luego lo desarrollo en futuros articulos:
http://www.watertronics.com/#/skyharvester
http://www.gdrc.org/uem/water/rainwater/introduction.html
http://ag.arizona.edu/pubs/water/az1052/harvest.html

Les anticipo algo.  Hacer este tipo de proyectos requiere dinero y planificacion.  Pero por ejemplo, algunas jurisdicciones en los Estados Unidos requieren tanques de retencion para los golpes de agua de por ejemplo: estacionamientos de centros comerciales.

Mencionando entonces que los programas de planificacion necesitan ver globalmente los efectos que han tenido el desarrollo de tantos proyectos residenciales y hacer desvios o estructuras de control para maejar el cambio.  Tambien esta accion corregiria la tendencia a ver proyectos como islitas y no como un todo.  Van viendo porque es tan necesario ese Plan de Uso de Terrenos?

Ese plan de uso, puesto como layers de GIS o como capas en Google Earth pudiese permitir que futuros profesionales y voluntarios que queremos un cambio puedan aportar a una solucion entre todas las partes, que deberia ser la intencion de la reglamentacion y las agencias.

Para entrar en ese tema pueden ver este panfleto que desarrollo Sea Grant para grupos comunitarios que quieren resolver problemas ambientales.  Es bueno, siempre y cuando no le metan la maldita politica barata:
http://www.seagrantpr.org/outreach/water_quality_files/guiaambientalcompletafinal.pdf

Se que dejo muchos cabos sueltos.  Pero creo prudente dejar el tema aqui y lo desarrollo en temas especificos.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Burger King enters Greenwashing Bandwagon



A trend worth watching. Last night I stopped at a remodeled Burger King in Bayamon and found, of all things, spaces reserved for 'hybrid parking'. In disbelief I pondered on what is the purpose of giving an incentive to a hybrid car driver to park close to the door to eat hamburgers, when beef is one of the least green feeds to have.

Handicapped parking, although abused here in the Island, has a purpose and is justified.
Expectant mothers parking, although I dislike, still has an honorable purpose. But a special parking just for having a hybrid? Even when in some cases, being a hybrid has closer emmisions to a regular car (Escalade Hybrid anyone?).

In my opinion doing such an action is plain wrong. Yet 'enviromentalists' all over are pushing bills to incentivate the practice. Even getting LEED points credits while doing so. In the states (why everything American is always good in Puerto Rico) the practice is gaining acceptance in Ikea, Home Depot and now Burger King. That everyone does it does not mean it is good. In my opinion it is all greenwashing (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenwash)

From Wikipedia:
How to spot Greenwashing
There are many different ways to spot a company that may be greenwashing. Here is a list of things to consider when buying a product to tell whether it’s really green or just advertisement.
Poor use of scientific facts or the lack of any scientific facts.
The use of buzz words like ”carbon intensity”, “sustainable development”, “carbon offsets”, “clean technology”. These terms may be used to distract consumers from researching further into the product.
Look at the seal or environmental label on the product. Some labels like "Green Seal" and a few others labels are credible. They are backed by a strict independent certification. All other eco labels on products are unregulated and the manufacturer has the authority to use them even if the products are not green.
Use common sense. If the claims don’t feel right they may not be. For example is BP greener because they changed their name to a more eco friendly Beyond Petroleum?
Look out for companies that produce green products that actually pollute the environment more by making their products green. For example energy efficient light bulbs save energy, but if not produced responsibly and recycled correctly they can damage the environment more than they help.
Green pictures and pictures of nature can also be used to imply a product is green. Just because a product has flowers or a forest on it doesn’t mean it is green or eco friendly.
Look out for irrelevant claims, mainly, when a company focuses on one small green attribute when the rest of the company or product is un-green.
These are some simple ways to spot greenwashing when you buy a product or see ads on TV. If you feel a company may be greenwashing the best way to verify is to simply do some research. A good site to verify any suspicions is the greenwashing index.
It is the 'green mentailty' presented by greedy marketers that are green by sucking the green cash from stupid executives that offset their guilt by buying carbon credits. That is another story.
Finally, some experience from other jurisdictions:
Why do fast food companies, those that have the worst environmental sustainability, insist on using obscure green technologies? Why things like the Motion Power technology in some parkings on the United States? To give the appearance of being green, and so the clients visiting the store think they are being green by just being there....linkage below
On this case just one word. Why get power from running drive thru vehicles? Isn't it just simpler to get your fat ass off the car and enter the store, instead of waiting 5 to 10 minutes on a line to place an order on a drive thru lane, with the motot idling and eating food in containers that are as large as the food portion you are eating.
In my opinion, this is just corporate greenwashing sold like the Indulgences of days past.
Tags en Blogalaxia


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...